Murray Bookchin ­- The Next Revolution (Review)

  • user warning: Table 'cache_views_data' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: SELECT data, created, headers, expire, serialized FROM cache_views_data WHERE cid = 'audio:block_1:results:e81564ca28d2c996fbced007412750b6' in /var/www/public/includes/cache.inc on line 27.
  • user warning: Table 'cache_views_data' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: UPDATE cache_views_data SET data = 'a:3:{s:6:\"result\";a:6:{i:0;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"7729\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:70:\"Anarchism, the left and fighting austerity in Greece - audio interview\";s:7:\"_random\";s:20:\"0.008676322185132953\";}i:1;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"8683\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:91:\"Rojava: Eyewitness to a women\'s revolution - report back from a May 2018 trip at #DABF 2018\";s:7:\"_random\";s:19:\"0.01037519146723225\";}i:2;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"8118\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:103:\"Refusing to Wait: Anarchism and Intersectionality - \"Without justice there can be no love.\"--bell hooks\";s:7:\"_random\";s:20:\"0.016148872688551315\";}i:3;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"7796\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:105:\"Priceless land: Resisting Displacement in Colombia ; resisting Fracking in Ireland - Audio from DABF 2014\";s:7:\"_random\";s:20:\"0.020789630730440496\";}i:4;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"5007\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:45:\"Torab Saleh on the Iranian revolution - Audio\";s:7:\"_random\";s:20:\"0.021555267294454637\";}i:5;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"8276\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:55:\"Bodily Autonomy at the Intersections - audio from #DABF\";s:7:\"_random\";s:20:\"0.023490427083792564\";}}s:10:\"total_rows\";i:166;s:5:\"pager\";a:5:{s:9:\"use_pager\";s:1:\"0\";s:14:\"items_per_page\";i:6;s:7:\"element\";i:0;s:6:\"offset\";i:0;s:12:\"current_page\";i:0;}}', created = 1565448146, expire = 1565448446, headers = '', serialized = 1 WHERE cid = 'audio:block_1:results:e81564ca28d2c996fbced007412750b6' in /var/www/public/includes/cache.inc on line 112.
  • user warning: Table 'cache_views_data' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: SELECT data, created, headers, expire, serialized FROM cache_views_data WHERE cid = 'video:block_1:results:bdcee2955c593dc50b03a37988e6af66' in /var/www/public/includes/cache.inc on line 27.
  • user warning: Table 'cache_views_data' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: UPDATE cache_views_data SET data = 'a:3:{s:6:\"result\";a:3:{i:0;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"8681\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:53:\"Pushing Back the Alt Right - #DABF 2018 video & audio\";s:7:\"_random\";s:21:\"0.0008702939384340252\";}i:1;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"8406\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:97:\"Video tour of previous Dublin eviction by injunction sites on the morning of Apollo House hearing\";s:7:\"_random\";s:20:\"0.016508121058818066\";}i:2;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"8041\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:64:\"Anarchist Bloc on the April 18 Bin Your Bills Water Charge March\";s:7:\"_random\";s:19:\"0.02502725741362875\";}}s:10:\"total_rows\";i:195;s:5:\"pager\";a:5:{s:9:\"use_pager\";s:1:\"0\";s:14:\"items_per_page\";i:3;s:7:\"element\";i:0;s:6:\"offset\";i:0;s:12:\"current_page\";i:0;}}', created = 1565448146, expire = 1565448446, headers = '', serialized = 1 WHERE cid = 'video:block_1:results:bdcee2955c593dc50b03a37988e6af66' in /var/www/public/includes/cache.inc on line 112.
  • user warning: Table 'cache_views_data' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: SELECT data, created, headers, expire, serialized FROM cache_views_data WHERE cid = 'Random_PDF:block_1:results:a81c5b2d52af9e9b584105b59542ff7d' in /var/www/public/includes/cache.inc on line 27.
  • user warning: Table 'cache_views_data' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: UPDATE cache_views_data SET data = 'a:3:{s:6:\"result\";a:2:{i:0;O:8:\"stdClass\":5:{s:3:\"nid\";s:3:\"347\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:27:\"Red and Black Revolution 10\";s:21:\"node_revisions_teaser\";s:1090:\"<p><img align=\"right\" hspace=\"3\" src=\"http://www.wsm.ie/attachments/jan2006/rbr10.jpg\" vspace=\"3\" /> Issue 10 of the WSM magazine Red and Black Revolution published Autumn 2005</p>\r\n<p><a href=\"http://www.wsm.ie/c/lessons-dublin-bin-tax-campaign-interview\"><br />\r\n Interview: Looking Back On The Battle of The Bins and Lessons Learnt</a><br />\r\n <a href=\"http://www.wsm.ie/c/communism-history-definition-open-software-anarchism\">Communism: What&rsquo;s In A Word</a><br />\r\n <a href=\"http://www.wsm.ie/c/environmentalism-class-community-anarchism\">Enviromentalism: Class and Community Struggle</a><br />\r\n <a href=\"http://www.wsm.ie/c/anarchys-cossak-nestor-makhno-review-skirda\">Book Review: Anarchy&rsquo;s Cossak; a review of the latest book on Makhno</a><br />\r\n <a href=\"http://www.wsm.ie/c/look-situationists-paris-dada\">Situationism and Anarchism</a><br />\r\n <a href=\"http://www.wsm.ie/c/new-direction-zapatistas\">A New Direction For The Zapatistas</a></p>\r\n<p><strong><a href=\"http://www.wsm.ie/sites/default/files/rbr10.pdf\">PDF of Red &amp; Black Revolution 10</a></strong></p>\r\n\";s:21:\"node_revisions_format\";s:1:\"2\";s:7:\"_random\";s:19:\"0.05790696112244107\";}i:1;O:8:\"stdClass\":5:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"8119\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:60:\"Solidarity Times leaflet for August 29th Water Charges march\";s:21:\"node_revisions_teaser\";s:1254:\"<p><img alt=\"\" src=\"/sites/default/files/SolidarityTimesCover.jpg\" style=\"width: 350px; height: 494px; margin: 3px; float: right;\" />We are the crisis of Irish Water! We do not want to have our water commodified, metered, and privatised. We know why this is happening &ndash; to increase the wealth and privilege of a global financial capitalist class and their political servants in the EU and Ireland.</p>\r\n<p>We refuse to bow to them. We have gotten up before dawn to stop water meter installation on our streets. We have organised meetings in our communities. We have marched in our thousands and in our hundreds of thousands, shouting &ldquo;Enough!&rdquo; and &ldquo;No way, we won&rsquo;t pay!&rdquo; and &ldquo;Shove your meters up your arse!&rdquo; We are not just angry, we are determined.&nbsp;</p>\r\n<p>We have forced this government into climb-downs and concessions, and we will do the same to the next one. We have decided to boycott Irish Water. We are encouraging our friends, co-workers and neighbours to do the same. Our community of communities is strong and growing stronger. We will keep on growing. When we break Irish Water, we will clear the rubble and grow real solidarity, real co-operation and real community in its place.</p>\r\n\";s:21:\"node_revisions_format\";s:1:\"2\";s:7:\"_random\";s:18:\"0.0615636716238816\";}}s:10:\"total_rows\";i:73;s:5:\"pager\";a:5:{s:9:\"use_pager\";s:1:\"0\";s:14:\"items_per_page\";i:2;s:7:\"element\";i:0;s:6:\"offset\";i:1;s:12:\"current_page\";i:0;}}', created = 1565448146, expire = 1565448446, headers = '', serialized = 1 WHERE cid = 'Random_PDF:block_1:results:a81c5b2d52af9e9b584105b59542ff7d' in /var/www/public/includes/cache.inc on line 112.
Date:

Despite being a pathbreaking figure from the 1960s onward in anarchist, green, and directly­ democratic political circles ­ having predicted early on the significance of ecological issues and technology to left­wing social struggles ­ Murray Bookchin today remains unknown to many on the left, and to those who do know of him he remains controversial.

Disliked by class struggle anarchists and Marxists for his advocacy of community organising over workplace organising, and by anarchists involved in single ­issue activism for their lack of organisation and supposed concern with personal rebellion over social change, he made quite a few enemies in his last days for fiery polemics directed at his intellectual opponents. While his supporters in organisations like New Compass defend him for his consistency, others argue that he ended up alienating potential allies by refusing to ever waver on his specific revolutionary vision: focused on creating a municipal­ confederation of ecological communities practicing direct­ democracy, founded on a philosophy of science, reason, and humanism.

This new collection of essays from the last few years of his life may provide a useful entry­ point of his philosophical and political project called social ecology and generate further debate for the future of libertarian socialist organising in an age of increasing militarism and climate crisis.

 

 

 

New wine or new bottle?

The first essay, The Communalist Project, has been published before and is by far the weakest. Written after Bookchin had distanced himself from anarchism, it is replete with historical distortions and errors about anarchist theory and practice ­ which Bookchin himself attacked Marxists for making in the 1960s. It comes across as a disingenuous rewriting of his former philosophy, knocking down straw-man after straw-man in an attempt to boost his own new political project called Communalism.

One could argue that Bookchin in fact never really left the social anarchist tradition, merely felt the need to distance himself from a label he saw as being irredeemable due to its increasing associations with primitivists, postmodernists, and lifestylists. From his own descriptions, Communalism could be viewed as a revamped version of anarcho­-communism ­ in that it seeks a community­ directed economy instead of the worker­ directed economy desired by most anarcho-­syndicalists.

Ecology and the future of the left

Most of the other essays cover familiar topics of interest, from the importance of ecology and the urban environment to political organising (years before Autonomist Marxists like Hardt and Negri), the crucial need to root one’s ideas in Enlightenment humanism over what he saw as the irrationality of postmodernism, critiques of nationalism, and the potential of popular assemblies as organs of a new participatory democracy.

The final essay, The Future of the Left, is from a contemporary perspective the most interesting. Bookchin gives a broad overview of revolutionary left traditions of the past, offering critical commentary of what went right and wrong with anarchism, Marxism, and other revolutionary doctrines. He stresses the importance of reason, Enlightenment humanism, direct democracy, and the ecological worldview, while attacking the traditional left’s excessive focus on class and economic issues, pointing out the need to appeal to people simply as “the people”, instead of “workers”, which he finds reduces them to their economic function and discounts the significance of trans­-class power hierarchies that cannot be reduced economics.

A matter of emphasis

It’s difficult to say what he would have made of the recent Occupy and Squares movements that kicked off in 2011. His comments about the flaws of the alter­-globalisation protests indicate he would have criticised their focus on consensus decision ­making over majority voting and their lack of a coherent program and systematic body of ideas. Though he would likely have praised the attempts to get people involved in grassroots democracy, unify class and tras­-class forms of social struggle, and bring environmental issues to the forefront of political discussion.

Looking at the collection a a whole, Bookchin perhaps under emphasised the role of class and workplace organising in social struggle, but no more so than Marxists and class struggle anarchists have overemphasised it, often relegating issues like race, gender, sexuality, and ecology to secondary importance; issues that can be sorted out "after the revolution". Whether traditional class struggle against capital and the state is indeed inferior to Bookchin’s form of community­ struggle against all forms of hierarchy and domination is an open question, and one that deserves consideration.

Given the impact social ecology has had on the recent Rojava Revolution, this collection can act as a compelling gateway to a thinker whose ideas could provide valuable lessons for future anti-­authoritarian theory and practice.

WORDS: EOIN O’CONNOR

  This article is from issue 11 of the Irish Anarchist Review

 

Like what you're reading?
Find out when we publish more via the
WSM Facebook
& WSM Twitter